Dynasty Metrics
DYNASTY ANALYTICS
// HEAD-TO-HEAD

J.J. McCarthy vs Caleb Williams

Caleb Williams is the better dynasty asset, carrying a 89% DME edge over J.J. McCarthy in SUPERFLEX leagues (7,624 vs 847) — backed by an ascending age-curve, a stronger positional rank (QB3).

J.J. McCarthy headshot
J.J. McCarthy
QB454MINQB · 23y
DME VALUE DME
847
+5% age curve — Ascending youth (age 23) — room to grow into a larger role.
Caleb Williams headshot
Caleb Williams
QB31CHIQB · 24y
DME VALUE DME
7,624
EDGE
+5% age curve — Ascending youth (age 24) — room to grow into a larger role.
MORE QB COMPARISONS
J.J. McCarthy vs Josh AllenJ.J. McCarthy vs Lamar JacksonJ.J. McCarthy vs Drake MayeJ.J. McCarthy vs Joe Burrow
Run this trade in the calculator

See full age-adjusted fairness, verdicts and counter-offers — free, no login.

Start free